- 869 -
Enhanced Triode Mode
Integrated SE Amplifier
A little history...
[insert drum roll]
"Tim de Paravicini has been credited by many
with starting the valve renaissance in England.
Tim, who has worked around all corners of the globe, has unique ideas and designs, a clean-sheet break from the designs of old. Too many of his competitors use old, tired designs to flavour the sound, and do not seek to advance the state of the art.
Enter the E.A.R 859 (predecessor to the 869)...
The E.A.R 859 was designed to be 'the best' Single-Ended Triode amplifier on the market.
Tim, as always, was keen to cut a new path through the forest and ignored the weak and vulnerable, inferior and obsolete direct-heated triodes (such as the 300B). He based his design on his favorite valve, the 6KG6/EL519, developing a new operating mode called Enhanced Triode Mode, or ETM for short.
This revolutionary new circuit cleverly tied the control grid (G1) to the cathode, removing the potential difference between the two, and fed the control signal into the screen grid (G2). This gave better, more linear results than directly heated triodes, with the added advantages of high anode power rating, good valve availability and maximum reliability.
This was put together in a DC-connected, low feedback pure Class A circuit, that automatically compensates for valve spread, maintaining excellent, reliable, sound quality for an extended period of time.
The proof of the pudding is in the eating, and the E.A.R 859 does not disappoint. It has that unique valve sound, but without the usual single-ended 'mush'.
All of Tim de Paravicini's designs bear the influence of his experience designing and using professional products, and this clearly shows.
Hi-fi reviewers around the world have acclaimed the E.A.R 859 as, to quote one South African Magazine, 'The finest Integrated Valve Amp we've ever heard.'
In England, Ken Kessler of Hi-Fi News summed up his review by saying 'Yes, yes, yes, yes'.
Even in Japan, the world's most diverse and intense market, the E.A.R 859 has won critical acclaim from Japan's most prestigious hi-fi magazine Stereo Sound. It was honored so highly as to be nominated for the Component of the Year award, and was highly commended. An outstanding achievement for a thirteen watt single-ended valve amplifier.
However, there's nothing that can't be improved, and if anyone could improve the 859, it would, of course, have to be its original designer..."
- Review of E.A.R. 859 -
"Common to all hobbies is the threat of repetition, of the sameness which can kill progress, and interest, stone dead. So hi-fi enthusiasts, retailers, manufacturers and journalists end up pursuing novelty not just for the sake of it, but because we need it. But there's one individual to whom I can always turn if I need a jolt of some sort, be it genuine controversy or merely a new approach to a familiar problem...
Tim de Paravicini of Esoteric Audio Research (aka, E.A.R) is known as, among other things, 'the wild man of audio', 'the best tube circuit designer alive'; and a few less flattering names which, at the very least, attest to both the fear he instills in his opposition and the respect which even his rivals hold for him.
In the past couple of years, he's won me over with E.A.R products from both ends of the price scale, the 26,000 Yoshino amplifier and the 300 834P phono amp. T hen there are his awe-inspiring Revox G36 tape deck mods, his regular range of E.A.R electronics, his work in the recording industry, ad infinitum.
But Tim's latest wheeze just might be the most political move yet, something which borders on the guerrilla, and we at HFNIRR are willing, nay, grateful accomplices.
Tim's proposition is a response to an epidemic of what, in the UK market in particular, he regards as third-rate amplifiers passing themselves off as the leading edge in tube development. He's shocked by the hype, the price tags and, above all, the claims of originality attributed to such designs. But this is not the place to enter into a debate about the history of valve circuit design, because Tim alone could wax furiously for, oh, six hours non-stop.
Suffice to say, he finds a bit too much revisionism going on today, to say nothing of the wholesale appropriation of others' work. So he's chosen to put his money where his mouth is by placing in the public domain a fresh design, one which he also markets as a regular E.A.R model for those who would rather not build an amplifier from scratch. He is giving this circuit away, gratis, free of charge, gornisht. So it can't be ripped off.
We at HFN&RR are so taken with the unit that we're offering kit versions of it (though not the built-up version, which is available only from retailers) in this month's Accessories Club. The complete circuit diagram is published in this article with E.A.R.'s approval. Tim de Paravicini feels confident that skilled hobbyists will be able to follow the circuit, building the amp from raw components they've sourced independently (E.A.R will sell its transformers to such readers who want to build from scratch, sourcing their own bits). It's probably his way of raising two fingers to those he regards as the new barbarians.
But first, I should let Tim tell you, in his own words, about the Esoteric Audio Research 859 'Enhanced Triode Mode' SE Integrated Amplifier...
'Designing our single-ended amplifier has proven far more difficult than I first imagined. The first major problems were the reliability and quality of current production triode tubes. Most of the fashionable tubes tested (300Bs etc) offered very poor performance. Driven hard in single-ended mode these tubes give l0W, but with poor reliability - only a few hundred hours use - and diabolical performance. I wanted a minimum of 10W of clean single-ended power, plus a good few thousand hours of valve life. Surely no customer wants to be spending hundreds of pounds on new output valves every couple of months.'
'After deciding that current production directly-heated triodes were more of ornamental value than anything you would want to use in a powerful single-ended amplifier, I turned to conventional tetrodes and pentodes. Sadly, as was the case with the above-mentioned triodes, none could deliver the goods in either clean power or longevity. Parallel single-ended was tried but dismissed on sonic grounds; push-pull with the same valves sounded much better, but it kind of defeated the object somehow...'
'My own 549 amplifiers provided the inspiration. They use four PL519 valves in parallel push-pull to deliver over 250W midband. Most of these are used by professionals in the studio environment, equipment which is left on 24 hours a day, seven days a week. The reliability of these valves has been superb. An average set lasts 20,000 hours - that's three years continuous use. After reliability tests, the similar EL509 was chosen as the output valve. It's cheap and lasts for ages.'
'I was still unhappy. I really wanted a triode as an output valve, so after much head-banging I came up with 'Enhanced Triode Mode' operation. Tests I conducted had the control grid (or Grid 1) connected to the cathode, with the audio signal fed into the valve via the screen grid (Grid 2). Operated like this, the output valve behaved as a true triode. In normal triode mode, the screen grid is usually strapped to the anode. This is not as successful as Enhanced Triode Mode.'
'In the solid-state world, MOSFETs operate in an "enhanced" mode with the "gate" (equivalent to a valve's grid) positive with respect to the source (equivalent to the cathode). Normal FETs are biased in exactly the same way as a power valve, with the gate negative with respect to the source.'
'The input circuit is a cascade to give the high 150-times gain needed to drive the Enhanced Triode Mode correctly. Actual drive is via a cathode follower, DC-coupled to the ETM's grid. A minimum amount of negative feedback is taken from the output transformer, just to make sure that the amplifier stays spotlessly clean even when driving difficult loads. DC feedback is also applied across the three stages, as a self-biasing mechanism.' This provides rock-like stability, which helps to further lengthen the life of the valves as well as to improve sound quality.
Translated into a product you can buy, there is now a relatively compact, anguish-free gem called the E.A.R 859...
The E.A.R 859 measures 400x400xl50mm (wdh) and weighs a not insubstantial 19kg. The look alone is enough to justify Tim's nickname for it: 'Son of Yoshino'.
In deluxe form (the kit is available either gilt or guilt-free), the unit bears a perfectly-finished chrome fascia, plated transformer covers and deluxe, gilded knobs. These control the playback level and the selection of up to six line sources. (Quite rightly, Tim suggests that customers acquire an E.A.R 834 for phono duties, as one of the line inputs has been designated 'phono'. Maybe he's right in presupposing that those who own single-ended triode amps also use vinyl.)
Hidden from view are the three PCC88's used for pre-amplifier duties, while there for all to see are the EL509's, right at the front. Other illumination comes from the press-button on/off switch, which glows a tangerine hue.
The review sample was absolutely identical to the production and deluxe kit versions, but minus the cages which protect the two output tubes. The rear of the unit contains the sockets and the proper binding posts, which you can connect to loads as low as 4 ohms. Mains enters via an IEC socket.
A nice touch is that the large badge gracing the area between the Yoshino-branded transformers features a map of the sockets, so you can just reach over and pretty much hit the right inputs.
What Tim's description doesn't tell you is that the 859 is a true Class A design delivering 13W per channel, both channels driven and over a power bandwidth of 20Hz to 20kHz +/- 0.5dB. Frequency response is 5Hz to 50kHz for 1W output, sensitivity for full power is 200mV, and distortion at full power is <2% at lkhz and <5% from 20Hz to 20kHz.
By now I would hope that the more mature, balanced and open- minded readers have accepted that specifications only have meaning when designing a product or, if dealing with oddball hardware, when matching amps to speakers.
Even then most specs are meaningless, especially those for power output. Otherwise, how would you explain that a seemingly minuscule 13W per channel can be deemed more than adequate even with speakers which aren't ultra-high-sensitivity designs? I wasn't surprised when the E.A.R 859 worked a treat with 15,000-worth of Wilson WATT V/Puppy V because the latter's sensitivity is sufficiently high at 90dB/w/m.
Normal partnering equipment, however, would be 300 watters from Krell or Audio Research or Mark Levinson. Yet the 859 drove them well enough to elicit shouts of 'Turn it down!'. What of Sonus Faber Minima Amators? LS3/5As? ATC SCM10s? How could the 859 do so well?
It should be obvious by now that single-ended triode amps capable of producing a maximum baker's dozen of watts are not about specifications. They're about sound, which is a shock! horror! statement to the myriad hi-fi enthusiasts who still believe all the garbage forced down their throats by the mass-market brands of the early 1970's.
The E.A.R 859 doesn't even look like a conventional amp (tube or otherwise), and it's absolutely minimalist right down to a lack of balance control. But hook it up to any speaker less voracious than an Apogee, with a decent source, and you have high-end amplification for less than most high-end brands charge for a power supply. Or an interconnect.
So scary is the E.A.R 859's prowess that I had to rethink a review of another triode system selling for twice the price of the built-up E.A.R. Factor in the savings the kit will offer, and it spells curtains for just about every low-power triode tube amp under two grand.
What I heard was the transparency and sweetness that all tube fans cherish, with a natural warmth which placed Sheffield Lab's 'Power of Seven' CD in the room, each voice with its own turf.
The sax on BB King's 'Don't Get Around Much Anymore' on our free CD had an in-your-face honk made up of the requisite readiness, metallics and breathiness. And presence? The 859's way with imaging is the polar opposite of the typical Linn signature. You listen into the soundstage, with even off-axis seating provided with a satisfactory sonic picture. Heavy metal, large orchestral, reggae - I ran through something like 50 CDs before accepting that, yes, the E.A.R 859 is capable of exceeding everything that its specs suggest.
It is, in a word, complete. It delivers a sound so truly musical that you find yourself not giving a damn about audiophile concerns. Alas, you will not accept that as a verdict because you know, as I do, that it is not perfect. If it were, I'd be saying that all other amplifiers have been made redundant.
Instead, you know what I'm going to say because of the 'Nature of The Beast'. I'm going to confirm that, yes, the power is a limiting factor if you have voracious speakers, an exceptionally large room and/or a penchant for earsplitting levels. And, yes, the bass lacks that final crispness and that thundering steamroller effect that passes for lower registers in this era of morons with a lust for the nausea-inducing BPM born at the rave party. But so what? Such individuals are partially deaf, intellectually deprived and listen only to portables or PA systems.
Am I happy with the E.A.R 859?
Would I buy the kit if I felt confident enough to solder?
Would I buy the built-up version if I couldn't solder?
Would I recommend it to friends?
Yes, Yes, Yes, Yes.
The E.A.R 859 has provided me with more fun than I can describe. And I didn't even have the pleasure of building it."
—Ken Kessler, Hi-Fi News, 11/94.
Enter the E.A.R 869...
The E.A.R 869 has the basic output topology of the 859, with a revised output transformer,
plus a modified input stage with one extra small-signal valve, allowing a small but significant increase in output power to 15W per channel, and even better control of operating conditions irrespective of valve parameters.
In addition, the input options have been extended so that the amplifier can be used as a basic power amp, bypassing the selector switch.
- Review of E.A.R/Yoshino 869 -
"The 869 SET is, as the name says, a single ended triode integrated built around the 519 pentodes. It shares the same output topology with its popular precedessor, the 859, but has a little more power (15W against 13W), sports a revised output transformer, and a modified input stage with one extra small-signal tube or valve as Tim de Paravici, the head designer of E.A.R, likes to call them. Besides 6 line level inputs, there are inputs to bypass the selector switch thanks to which the amplifier can be used as a genuine power amplifier.
The 519 pentode output tube operates in the 'enhanced triode mode' meaning that 'the control grid is connected to the cathode, with the audio signal fed into the valve via the screen grid whereas in 'normal triode mode', the screen grid is usually strapped to the anode. Operated like this, the output valve behaved as a true triode.' I asked Tim whether the 519 in his triode amps really behaves like a true triode, and you can read his answer here. On the other hand it is well known that Tim appreciates reliability, durability and low price as much as the choices he makes for the circuitry, those qulities being at least as imporant for him in choosing the output tube for the amp.
'The input circuit is a cascade to give the high 150-times gain needed to drive the Enhanced Triode Mode correctly. Actual drive is via a cathode follower, DC-coupled to the ETM's grid. A minimum amount of negative feedback is taken from the output transformer, just to make sure that the amplifier stays spotlessly clean even when driving difficult loads. DC feedback is also applied across the three stages, as a self-biasing mechanism.' As can be seen, when the power tube is operated in the enhanced triode mode the amp requires some negative feedback for the best linearity, zero NF ETM SETs do not exist.
With well over 20 kg, the E.A.R 869 is a heavy beast even considering that SET's are heavy because of their massive OPTs. If the design of some other E.A.R amps looks a bit exotic and over-stylized to my Scandinavian eye - round forms in technical products are always a bit risky -, the E.A.R 869 looks honest and simple enough. It's a good looking amp without unnecessary embellishment. Even the silver/gold color combo didn't bother me although it's likely that surface gloss and shiny outlooks were primarily meant to please the markets in Far East Asia.
If I think of all the audio products I've reviewed in past 15 years, it's not too difficult to classify them in three categories: those that are obvious disappointments (not so many), those that are good, solid, basically flawless performers in different ways but not more (the majority), and those that pull over and go under one's skin (every now and then). That the distribution is such is only human. There have been more obvious stoppers than the E.A.R 869 but nevertheless it definitely belongs the last category.
Its sound possesses many strong points. The ability to follow the dynamics of the music is one: the amp goes quieter and quieter and quieter, and waits until the very last moment before it explodes with music. It appears to have souvereign authority over the music and reigns it with a stable grip. When music requires (this applies mainly to classic material) that certain events are highlighted and emphasized, the 869 does exactly that - does it better than many more mortal integrates, tube or solid state. And so on. But the crucial point is that the 869 pesuaded me to listen to it, and by implication made music feel good and right. That is a clear sign of a high quality audio product. It doesn't happen every day.
That the sound is of high quality ain't interesting. In what ways, is. Here we need to do some conceptual preparation. Suppose something like 'a SET sound' exists. Suppose further that the 869 is one of the amps that possess the said SET sound. Then, as far as my experience and understanding of these things goes, we need to establish a new category for the 869. And the reason is that the 869 does not sound like a 'typical' SET amp whether from the directly heated 2A3/300B pool or from the group of single ended pentode amps (triode trapped or not) such as EL84 amps with which I compared it.
As to the latter, the 869 has more energy and livelyhood in the upper midrange to low treble region but sounds a tad darker and rounded in the upper treble. It did not have the same delicasy over the highest harmonics as my NOS Mullard EL84s did in a EL84 SET. But as to the rest, the E.A.R 869 is a winner: better control, drive, bass, dynamics, stability, serenity, carnality. Where the EL84 SET with its 4-6 watts got congested and thin during loud passages of the music sample, the 869 exhaled freely with no signs of compression whatsoever.
On the other hand, the sound of the 869 does not have the same 'sophistication' (this is just a word, more important is what's behind it) and holographic transparence of the best direct heated SETs I've heard. If a 300B SET can sound 'beautiful' (it need not but let's suppose so), then the 869 sounds 'bold'. 'Bold' is a very apt word to describe how the 869 sounds in general. Direct, neutral, rhythmic and all that in a bold way.
Of the 300B and 2A3 amps, the 869 is more like the 2A3 in that it sounds less whimsy. If some 300B amps suffer from occasional bidirectional mental disorder, the 2A3 amps I've heard and the 869 sound wholesome. On the other hand, the 869 does not sound bold in a way Shindo amps 'typically' do: it doesn't have the same intensity, it doesn't give rise to similar long narratives, it doesn't get interwoven in music in that complex deep way that almost all Shindo amps (SETs or not) that I know do. As compared to Shindos, the 869 is like a BMW or Mercedes. It cares less of poetry and more of refined tactics and infallible strategies. So we need reserve a subcategory within the class of the SET sound for the type of bold sound the 869 represents.
When I auditioned the 869 as an integrated amp I had only relatively small 2-way speakers (AS, Harbeth, DIY, JPW). None of those has the resonance frequency below 50 Hz so I cannot verify how the 869, as an integrated, handles the 50Hz or below bass in a full-range dynamic loudspeaker. But within the limits of the monitors, the E.A.R 869 produced bass that had power, was relatively tight and extended, more so than the EL84 SET. But I also listened to the 869, as a low pass power amp (<500Hz) with my Lansing AGA horn speakers. The 15' woofer in the Altec 816 bass cabinet does not descend down much below 50 Hz either but certainly provides a better picture of the amps resources to reproduce bass notes from the mid-bass to upper bass region, and gives a very good idea of the amp's abilities in the critical upper bass to 400Hz region. As compared to 20W Class A solid state mono blocks, the 869 had a bit warmer and rounded bass but wasn't disturbingly slow, suggy or woollen either. It's a good bass amp.
However, most of the time I used the 869 as a high pass power amp (>500Hz) to drive the very sensitive HF sectoral horns. There was only very little background noise and the sound was superlative: punchy, airy and spatious (particularly audible echoes) basically showing the same virtues and qualities as it did as an integrated amp but this time more pronouncedly, and yet as I said, it wasn't like other SETs. Some people believe that in a two way active horn system one should only use two identical pairs of mono blocks or two identical stereo power amps. I'm not sure if that were the only way to happiness but I'm almost certain that two 869s in a horn system like mine would give very bold results." —Kari Nevalainen, InnerAudio
"Power wise, this amp will effortlessly drive my 89dB sensitivity speakers to greater levels without any apparent distortion than most would tolerate for extended listening, it will drive anything with at least 86+dB loudly in a 16' x 21' room such as I have, bass is well accounted for and quite honestly belittles many amps with higher rated outputs... I don't have any issue using it (and prefer it for it's beautiful sound quality, and greater image depth and width) instead of my Bryston 150wrms mono blocks on the same speakers, it is PLENTY loud!! Also, due to its excellent design and output transformers, it will drive electrostatics such as Quad 57's, 63's etc without even a blink ( to reasonable levels of course ), unlike many other so called powerful tube and many solid state amps....Obviously, the easier the load (i.e: impedance curve), the speakers present the more linear the power delivery; having said that, the 859 does have 4,8 and 16 ohm speaker taps for optimum matching... Allay your fears of muddled bass and rolled off highs, this amp featured neither with several pairs of speakers I have used with it; it suprised the hell out of my hifi-store-owning friend when we compared it to a pair of 28 watt per channel push-pull Audion Silver Night 300B monoblocks he was selling; his genuine quote: 'Man !..it sounds far louder and better than the Audions, my god, thats the best single ended amp I've bloody heard!!!' Trust me this is a very special amp, so go buy your own, 'cause you'll never pry this out of my sweaty palms." —coolhand
— — —
"Had an E.A.R 869 for a while last year...and thought it was glorious - both aesthetically and sonically. I used it with a pair of Red Rose Rosebud monitors which were hardly an obvious partner at only about 87db, and although I don't play at Bottleneck type levels, I never felt that it was struggling for power. I also recently had an E.A.R 8L6 integrated which is about 50 watts per channel but it didn't thrill me in the slightest, and I'd definitely choose the 869 despite the lower power." —unclepuncle
the revolution continues...
CLICK for Interviews with Tim de Paravicini
− Established 1973 −
"love what you listen with"
Los Angeles, California USA
AllegroSound et al assumes no responsibility for use or misuse of products, services, info, etc.
design & original content ©AllegroSound, los angeles, california, usa. all rights reserved.
− Established 1973 −
"love what you listen with"
Los Angeles, California USA